The Truth Behind 5 Common Tooth Extraction Myths

May 2, 2025

Woman smiling while holding a tooth

Many dental treatments are often portrayed in a negative light. Whether it’s exaggerations in movies and shows or stories you hear from other people, rumors can start circulating about different services. Teeth extractions are one of them that you may hear only bad things about. Many misconceptions surrounding this procedure are actually untrue! If you find out that you need to have a tooth removed, here are five common myths and the truth behind them.

Myth #1: Tooth Extractions Are Painful

This misunderstanding about tooth extractions is likely the most common one. The truth is that advances in modern dentistry tools and anesthesia make the procedure virtually pain-free!

Before it even begins, your dentist numbs the tooth and surrounding area with a powerful local anesthetic. Then, they use an elevator tool that gently puts even pressure on your tooth to loosen it. After, they use forceps to rock it back and forth, making a clean extraction! At most, you may feel some pressure, but it shouldn’t be outright pain.

Myth #2: Recovery From a Tooth Extraction Takes a Long Time

“A long time” can mean almost anything. Hearing those simple words can make it seem like a tooth extraction takes months or even years to heal. However, in reality, it can be as quick as two weeks, and even most people feel back to normal after less than a week! You may be sore for the first few days, but with your dentist’s aftercare instructions, you will recover quickly and easily.

Myth #3: Everyone Has to Have Their Wisdom Teeth Removed

In the past, dentists commonly recommended removing wisdom teeth as they began to erupt. However, many modern dentists agree that it’s not always necessary anymore! It depends on how your wisdom teeth come in and whether they pose a risk to your oral health. Your dentist can examine them and provide a better idea of whether they need to be removed.

Myth #4: Pulling Damaged or Infected Teeth is Always Best

Most dentists agree that it’s better to save a tooth than extract it. Natural teeth are very strong and reliable. Many restorative treatments can offer durable replacements, but they don’t provide the same gold standard for overall function and health as the pearly whites you’re born with. Root canals and crowns are some options that can restore a damaged tooth to its former glory.

Myth #5: You Don’t Have to Replace an Extracted Tooth

Plenty of people believe that there is no real need to replace a tooth after an extraction. In some cases, such as orthodontic treatments, it may be true, as it can help create space, allowing your teeth to move more easily to improve bite alignment. However, missing teeth can actually affect your mouth and smile as the root of your teeth naturally stimulate the jaw, keeping it strong and healthy.

Without them, the jawbone starts to deteriorate. Your body thinks you’re not using your jaw anymore and moves those minerals to other parts, which can change your facial appearance by causing wrinkles or sunken cheeks at an earlier age. Your teeth can also start to shift into the space, leading to crookedness, crowding, and even unconscious grinding!

There are many myths and misconceptions surrounding tooth extractions. While they can seem scary, most of them are untrue! You can always discuss your concerns with your dentist, and they will be happy to answer your questions.

About the Author

Dr. Publio Silfa is a proud third-generation dentist! He is committed to upholding the tradition of his predecessors in giving patients their most confident smile. Dr. Silfa uses modern dental techniques and technology to ensure effective and comfortable treatment. He is here for you during dental emergencies, including those that require an extraction. If you have any questions about tooth extractions, schedule an appointment or call us at (631) 646-1555.

Silfa dental Aesthetics